Within the context of software development, output is often assumed to be product size and input to be effort. A good understanding of software development including knowledge of the factors that impact productivity and historical trends analysis techniques based on software metrics experience questions often arise when analyzing productivity dataquestions often arise when analyzing productivity data. Although its earliest measurement was in lines of code per manhours worked, a better definition is the ratio between the functional value of software produced to the labor and expense of producing it. Project managers use software productivity measures to assess software development efficiency. Software productivity can be defined as the ratio between the functional values of software produced to the efforts and expense required for development. Sizerelated metrics indicating the size of outcomes from an activity. This benchmarking survey seeks to compare methods used to measure productivity across industries.
The it execs guide to software analysis and measurement. Given the increasing complexity of the software being developed and the concomitant rise in the typical project size, the productivity has not consistently improved. Although not perfect, we tradi tionally use software size as a measure of output for software development productiv ity sizeeffortfor example, 0. This enables benchmarking, for instance against the open industry database of the international software benchmarking standards group.
In particular we have no way of reasonably measuring productivity. Specifically, using software development metrics contributes to the following. But how do we measure output in a standardized way. Web productivity measurement and benchmarking springerlink. The role of benchmarking data in the software development and enhancement projects effort planning.
Business benefits of having software development productivity metrics in place. He has led software cost estimation and software measurement improvement activities in software companies of different sizes and from various domains e. Measuring productivity oecd manual measurement of aggregate and industrylevel productivity growth measures of productivity growth constitute core indicators for the analysis of economic growth. Issues traditionally, software productivity has been measured as a. Mar 26, 2018 the agile manifesto states, working software is the primary measure of progress.
Focuses attention on measurement and improvement 5. Speak to us today to learn more about how you can improve both the productivity of your development teams and the productivity of all other specialist teams that help you to plan, build, test and deliver software at scale. There are multiple ways to measure software development efficiency and. The problem of measuring software productivity qsm slim. Benchmarking industry data and improvement tutorial, oop. Explore how effective quality benchmarking and productivity measurement translates into successful transformation. The other half is usually been hidden under the piles of documentation, hours of calls, messages in slack, trello boardsthe data that keeps magic and insights for software development team leaders and project managers. Three of the four types of productivity are typically important in a software development or it departments. Treating velocity as a success measure is inappropriate.
Over the years, a number of different approaches for engineering productivity measurement have been proposed. The software industry is also troubled by very poor quality and very high cost structures due to the expense of software development, maintenance, and endemic problems with poor quality control. Benchmarking is the practice of comparing business processes and performance metrics to industry bests and best practices from other companies. Benchmarking software development productivity of cmmi. Virtually any objective measurement you can apply to the software development process can be gamed into submission. Under qps guidance, organizations can implement the appropriate processes, collect the right application and project data and analyze that data to make better decisions. Capers jones on the mess of software metrics aits benchmarking. Frequency and pervasiveness of productivity measurement. The agile manifesto states, working software is the primary measure of progress. Relationships among software metrics in benchmarking. Successful deployment strategies from software sizing to. How to calculate workplace productivity smartsheet. He considers multiple requirements of building or buying a businessgrade measurement engine, as well as how to implement it. Benchmarking is the systematic process of measuring ones performance against recognized leaders for the purpose of determining best practices that lead to superior performance when adapted and utilized.
The productivity of software development is one of the major concerns for project managers. Note that there are various methods to measure software size. The software decisionmakers guide to predictable software development the fraunhofer iese series on software and systems engineering kindle edition by trendowicz, adam. In software development, 2 factors are used to measure productivity. As projects get more complicated, managers stop learning from their perience. Software cost estimation, benchmarking, and risk assessment. Measurement and estimating program software measurement program software estimates. Generally, raw material productivity is less of a factor in developing software development most of the raw material is human knowledge and observable in labor productivity or tfp, but it becomes more of a factor when the software. We all know to laugh at lines of code as a productivity measure. This new iso, which is still in process of development, could be in a future useful in order to standardize the software benchmarking process and ensure good practices. However, there are many different approaches to productivity measurement and.
We work with you to identify the relevant productivity and quality of your environment and to compare your software development productivity. Software productivity measurement should account for your organizations development processes and environment. The role of benchmarking data in the software development. Top 10 software development metrics to measure productivity. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading software cost. Measuring and improving software development productivity. Benchmarking is comparing ones business policies, products, programmes, strategies, processes and performance metrics to industry bests and best practices or standard measurements from other companies. The best metrics for measuring software development productivity and efficiency are committodeploy time cdt. Successful deployment strategies from software sizing to productivity measurement. Profiling an enterpriselevel software development project in the context of productivity is necessary in order to objectively measure productivity of a software development project and to. Software measurement and metrics provide an accurate, objective approach to evaluating these key factors.
Software productivity empirical model for early estimation. Cii, 1995 to be successful, benchmarking should be implemented as a structured, systematic process. Development and implementation of an engineering productivity. The esa initiative for software productivity benchmarking and effort. The average productivity rate as well as the range of productivity is provided for each of the following industries. Benchmarking is used to measure performance using a specific indicator cost per unit of measure, productivity per unit of measure, cycle time of x per unit of measure or defects per unit of. Accurate measurements of software development and maintenance costs and accurate measurement of quality would be extremely valuable. Benchmarking against the industry or the competition identify practices that either promote or impede increased output and better quality im sure there are many others that could be added to the list. This new iso, which is still in process of development, could be in a future useful in order to standardize the software benchmarking process and ensure good. This paper is aimed at indicating the important role of using reliable benchmarking data in order to obtain valuable effort estimates for software development and enhancement projects, including. Benchmarking guide for software development and maintenance. Software productivity is a deceptively simple concept, but a matter of some debate. Jun 17, 2015 in this paper, data envelopment analysis variable returns to scale dea vrs model is applied to data collected on 79 software development projects from a leading cmmi level 5 organization.
Dcg software value, ledamc, and ti metricas release a guide that enables any company to analyze its software development performance in the context of average market performance and costs, facilitating improved resource and budget management. Benchmarking enables you to assess it productivity and demonstrate potential resource savings to executivelevel management. Some of positive productivity drivers from the dea best practice efficient projects point to good customer rapport and application familiarity. It is important to understand how that happens and how to change it. Benchmarking softwaredevelopment productivity ieee software. How do i measure the software development productivity. Software development productivity of european space. Satwinder singh bbsbec fatehgarh sahib abstractsoftware development efforts estimation is the process of predicting the most realistic use of effort required to develop or maintain software based on incomplete, uncertain andor noisy input. Making informed management decisions requires the right information, the kind of information that an effective software measurement program delivers. Productivity is the most important metric in performance measurement processes.
Dcg software value announces the software development productivity benchmarking guide. Issues traditionally, software productivity has been measured as a ratio between units of output and units of effort. It leaders across all industries are invited to attend this 30minute webinar exploring best practices in software sizing and measurement. Dimensions typically measured are quality, time and cost. Outsourcing agile software development outputbased metrics. Total metrics uses our extensive experience to ensure that the benchmarking process complies with international standards and is conformant with the isoiec standard 15939 information technology software measurement process. Solutions for improving software quality and productivity.
Software measurements quality software measurement. This is the case with most software development for the space sector, whether it be. We divide overall software effort into software development effort, software quality conformance effort eoc, and software maintenance nonconformance eonc effort due to poor software quality at delivery. The best metrics to measure the productivity of your software development are the metrics that you use to measure the business results. Software productivity measurement explanation free. This number should only be used to plan iterations. In a lengthy and comprehensive post for wired innovation insights, vincent delaroche explores the ins and outs of software analysis and measurement.
Measurement classification, segmentation, and organization. Enhancing custom applications for maximum productivity is a major goal of it. Software measurement and benchmarking qsm slimestimate. Benchmarking software development productivity benchmarking.
Benchmarking industry data and improvement tutorial, oop, munich, 30. The data will make your assertions more compelling and defendable. Benchmarking software development productivity of cmmi level. Oct 31, 2014 the book improving software development productivity contains practices, models and case studies to quantitatively support adoption of agile software development. This is the time it takes for the code to go from committing to deploy. Comparing team velocities is nonsense, because the metric is based on nonobjective estimates. In between, it could go through testing, qa, and staging, depending on your organization. Our reputation is built on integrity, knowledge and commitment to providing the highest quality services in the industry.
Productivity is commonly measured as the ratio of output to input. Software measurement and benchmarking benefits gain quantitative oversight of your organizations project or portfolio. This article examines a statistical analysis of a productivity variation involving a unique database containing 206 business software projects from 26 finnish companies. The data can easily be manipulated to serve anyones particular interests. Functional size measurement requires people with the expertise to carry out this activity. These approaches are discussed and the development of the cii benchmarking and metrics approach, a direct measurement approach, is presented for this research.
Some of the disadvantages of using functional size measurement methods for software sizing and estimation are. By having objective metrics, you can more easily identify improvement areas and monitor each effort made toward better development practices. Benchmarking your software projects against similar projects provides you with an measure of your it projects performance. Harness the power of your organizations software data to gain insights to best manage software development and support cost, schedule, and performance objectives. Agile metrics to measure productivity of your software.
Consulting total metrics helping manage software development. Total metrics has 15 years experience in benchmarking software development. This article will walk you through the different formulas to measure productivity at all levels employee, organization, and software and give some quick tips and tricks to improve productivity. Partitioning effort into software development and software quality metrics provides us a comprehensive model to measure productivity of software projects and to identify best practice projects. For each of these objectives, the common thread is that they all require measurement. Productivity is universally defined by output input. Aug 29, 2003 in particular we have no way of reasonably measuring productivity.
Software productivity measurement tools must be capable of completing an assessment that fits these development settings. Benchmarking allows you to compare the performance of your software developmentmaintenance project to other projects in the it industry. Benchmarking compares the cost of your completed projects to an industrybased estimate of the same projects cost. The authors provide productivity benchmarking equations that are useful both for estimating expected productivity at the start of a new project and for benchmarking a completed project for each business sector. They must be measured to evaluate performance and form part of a benchmarking program. Top 10 productivity metrics for software development infopulse. Dcg software value announces the software development. Outsourcing agile software development outputbased. Mei he, mingshu li, qing wang, ye yang, kai ye, an investigation of software development productivity in china, proceedings of the software process, 2008 international conference on making globally distributed software development a success story, may 1011, 2008, leipzig, germany. Productivity, of course, is something you determine by looking at the input of an activity and its output. Benchmark data looks at where others have been in years past and has no relevance to what you are doing today.
By focusing on endtoend productivity, you can optimize your time to value to accelerate the speed and quality of your software products. Team velocityhow many units of software the team typically completes in an iteration a. Benchmarking demonstrates to a business how productive its software development group is. The goal behind using precise metrics and measurement in software engineering is to identify and control what can affect software development and the project as a whole. Estimating and benchmarking success with functional size measurement manfred bundschuh, carol dekkers on. And the best measure of how efficient your software development is how quickly your software improves business results. Apr 18, 2017 the best metrics for measuring software development productivity and efficiency are committodeploy time cdt. This new iso, which is still in process of development, could be in a future useful in.
Top 10 productivity metrics for software development. Software productivity empirical model for early estimation of development mandeep singh, prof. Predictive software engineering pse is a framework that addresses bottlenecks of custom software products development and reconstructs the reliable approach. How do you calculate productivity in employees, an organization, or from office productivity software. Software development benchmarking can be done on any scale that is comparable. However, productivity is only 1 aspect of software development. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Benchmarking demonstrates to business sponsors whether software development is costeffective. In the context of productivity measurement in software. An investigation on the variation of software development. The results can be used to benchmark key aspects of productivity including.
Benchmarking as a tool for optimising software development. The pragmatic guide there are four primary objectives for analyzing the productivity of software development and maintenance. The role of benchmarking data in the software development and. Nov 11, 2012 there have been many valiant attempts to measure developer productivity, but all seem to end in less than successful territory. So to measure software productivity you have to measure the output of software development the reason we cant measure productivity is because we cant measure output.
1329 393 1599 1591 38 955 219 1193 1359 1380 1040 480 528 325 17 45 1616 1261 388 1313 1367 882 862 425 1008 261 103 1336 737 1528 1054 505 1551 436 20 576 809 391 1149 6 550 370 271 582 532 739